To answer this question i am going to critically evaluate the impact of direct work with children from a safeguarding perspective which will include children who have been placed in foster care as a direct consequence. Identify the implications of gillick competence on the ability to consent. Childrens capacity to make decisions sage research methods. Fraser competence because mrs gillick threatened to sue that her name was being used in such a way so now the judges name is used instead that was badly written but my excuse is im in my jim jams too. Gillick competence refers to the assessment that doctors could make in regards to whether a child under 16 has the capacity to consent to treatment without parental or guardian consent. It was long thought that a child lacked legal capacity to give valid consent in law regarding decisions such as living arrangements, contracts, or consenting to medicalsurgicaldental procedures. These include decisions about smoking, drinking alcohol, gambling, joining the army and taking part in sexual intercourse. It is also common to refer to the mature minor principle. It is task specific so more complex procedures require greater levels of competence.
Gillick competence the child possess a sufficient understanding and intelligence to enable him or her to understand fully what is proposed gillick v west norfolk and wisbech area health authority 1986 ac 112. The cqc will expect practice staff to understand when to apply each. Under no circumstances may this pdf file be placed on a network of any sort without our express permission. This factsheet briefly explains the meaning of these terms. When practitioners are trying to decide whether a child is mature enough to make decisions, they often talk about whether the child is gillick competent or. Gillick competency vs fraser guidelines the student room. The parents cannot overrule the childs consent when.
Competence is related to cognitive ability and experience and may be enhanced by education, encouragement etc there is a general duty for professionals to enhance the competence of children in their care. It is generally used in medicine but has implications for child protection. Childrens competence to consent depends on their maturity. Proposed guidelines for assessing gillick competence when to invoke gillick competence. It is most likely to be useful when dealing with older children. The right of a child under 16 to consent to medical examination and treatment, including immunization was decided. Pdf children, gillick competency and consent for involvement in. Gillick competence is a term originating in england and is used in medical law to decide whether a child 16 years or younger is able to consent to his or her own medical treatment, without the need for parental permission or knowledge. Protecting the virtual child the law and childrens consent to. We sought to manage the complex terrain of informed assent and consent, aiming to ensure that both the child and the parent understood the implications of engaging in the research. Recently released figures from the office for national statistics 2016 show that some 4160 girls under 16 became pregnant in england and wales in 2014. Pdf this paper looks at the issue of consent from children and whether the test of gillick.
This article reports the results of an investigation of the information used by legislators to determine the age at which minors may consent to treatment. Fraser guidance not the same as gillick the gillick test must not be confused with guidance on treating sexually active youngsters, writes mr robert wheeler. Describe the skills needed to assess capacity in children. Otherwise, someone with parental responsibility can consent for them. This is sometimes referred to as gillick competence as the right was established in the english case of gillick v west norfolk aha 1986 ac 112. Mag is a form of mac son used in old irish names before vowels. A uk term of art referring to the competence of a child under the age of 16 to consent to hisher own medical care, without the need for parental permission. Gillick competency and fraser guidelines nspcc factsheet july 2012 when deciding whether a child is mature enough to make decisions, people often talk about whether a child is gillick competent or whether they meet the fraser guidelines. Consent to treatment children and young people nhs.
However, there is often confusion regarding the meaning of these two terms and they are frequently used as substitutes for each other, as if they were interchangeable. Balancing childrens rights with the responsibility to. Avant gillick competence no protection for jehovahs. Gillick competency and fraser guidelines refer to a legal case which looked specifically at whether. When deciding whether a child is mature enough to make decisions, people often talk about whether a child is gillick competent or whether they meet the fraser guidelines. Sometimes legal advocates refer to young people as gillick competent, which means that the young person, according to the test. Gillick competence definition of gillick competence by. This article considers the requirements for gillick competence, it highlights the factors that must be considered when determining whether a child is competent to give consent to treatment. Special medical procedures, gillick competence and the family court where a special medical procedure for a child is proposed, parental consent to the procedure will be insufficient and an order of the family court will be required. This legal principal was approved by the high court of australia in secretary, department of health and community. Apr 09, 2014 the decision of the court of appeal in x v sydney childrens hospitals network 20 nswca 320 confirms that, while the court will respect the particular religious beliefs of a mature minor who is resisting treatment that is, someone under 18 who has achieved a sufficient level of understanding and maturity to enable them to understand fully what is proposed the ultimate. Gillick competency and fraser guidelines international centre for.
The term gillick competence is now widely used by lawyers and health practitioners dealing with young people wheeler 2006. In such cases, doctors and lawyers are called upon to assess whether the adolescent is indeed a mature minor, or in legal parlance gillick competent. Older children or rather mature minors may have sufficient understanding and intelligence to consent to health care treatment themselves. Can young people under 18 make their own decisions. The gillick standard arose from the high courts decision in gillick v west norfolk and wisbech area health authority 1985 3 all er 402 hl, which is binding in the. In a recent publication, the lack of consensus among u. West norfolk and wisbech area health authority 1985. The surname mc gillick is a patronymic adopted by a branch of the burkes of connacht, and originates from the irish mag uilic, meaning son of ulick. Mrs gillick took her health authority to court because they were supplying contraceptives to under 16yr olds without informing parents. Inconsistency among american states on the age at which. When assessing gillick competence for immunization, a health professional has to decide whether the child is or is not competent to make that particular decision. Mar 27, 2017 which is why its important gps understand the legal terms gillicks competence and frasers guidelines to protect the interests of young people, and themselves. Assessing gillick competence british journal of midwifery.
This is a legal terminology, also known as the fraser ruling, to describe a competency test. For a child to be gillick competent he or she must have suficient understanding and intelligence to enable him or her to understand fully what is. Children under the age of 16 can consent to their own treatment if theyre believed to have enough intelligence, competence and understanding to fully appreciate whats involved in their treatment. Capacity of children to make legal decisions gillick. Capacity of children to make legal decisions the childs wishes and decisions in the family courts. Gillick competence is a term originating in england and is used in medical law to decide whether a child under 16 years of age is able to consent to his or her own medical treatment, without the need for parental permission or knowledge. The children act itself gives no guidance on how to determine a childs capacity for under standing and it is accepted that the principles used in ascertaining gillick competence will apply. Gillick becomes relevant when the patient is under 16 years of age. Children, gillick competency and consent for involvement in research. Special medical procedures, gillick competence and the family. This factsheet outlines key findings from a 1985 judgement by the house of lords on a legal case which looked specifically. Written and compiled by the nspcc safeguarding information service december 2009 when deciding whether a child is mature enough to make decisions, people often talk about whether a child is gillick competent or whether they meet the fraser guidelines. Assessing gillick competence when treating children what you.
He commented on the responsibility of doctors to ensure adequate capacity. Gillick competency and fraser guidelines refer to a legal case which looked specifically at whether doctors should be able to give contraceptive advice or treatment to under 16year old girls without parental consent. When a child is regarded as gillick competent it means that they have the maturity to make their own decisions and understand the consequences and meaning behind. Gillick competence is a functional ability to make a decision. The gillick principle originated in the house of lords in 1985 and concerns the rights of children under 16. Gillick competency and fraser guidelines nspcc learning. When referring to the phrase gillick competence, commentators are normally discussing the ability of a minor to make his or her own choices and have such choices upheld by the law. Competence is a vital facet of the informed consent process.
How should paediatricians assess gillick competence. In r axon v secretary of state for health the gillick competence test. The diffi culty inherent in this is what constitutes suf ficient understandi ng is rather. A child who has such understanding is considered gillick competent or fraser competent. Competence and consent to treatment in children and adolescents. The gillick competency and fraser guidelines help people who work with children to balance the need to listen to childrens wishes with the responsibility to keep them safe. To manage teenage pregnancies effectively, midwives must be able to assess the childs competence to consent to their maternity care. Consent will be an issue in all interactions between practitioners and patients. The decision in the case of gillick is not written in a specific law statute but is part of whats called the uk common law a decision made on a particular issue taken in this case all the way to the house of lords which effectively sets a precedent. The need to assess a childs competence may occur when she wishes to make a controversial decision whose wisdom others dispute. Gillick competence is a term originating in england and is used in medical law to decide. A plea for consistency over competence in children. Fraser competence because mrs gillick threatened to sue that her name was being used in such a way so now the judges name is used instead that was badly written.
This paper aims to add to the discussion of when is the best time to test through an examination of how the law on medical treatment of children appears to be used in practice and how a careful examination of legal rulings might shed light upon best practice in this area. In situations where the child is gillick competent or able to consent for the purposes of s8 of the flra 1969, the high court, in. A person with parental responsibility will need to consent on their behalf. Children%20and%20young%20people%20in%20nz%20final%20version. Nov 30, 2015 gillick competence is a functional ability to make a decision. Gillick competence is widely use d as criterion to assess a childs maturi ty to make decisions. Most commonly, discussion relates to medical treatment and stems from the case of gillick v w norfolk and wisbech aha. Testing for carrier status for various genetic conditions often takes place during adolescence or young adulthood. Gillick competence describes the principle laid down by lord scarman in gillick v.
There is often confusion over the meaning of gillick competence and fraser guidelines. Children, gillick competency and consent for involvement in. Fraser guidelines is in reference to lord frasers involvement with the gillick case. The checklist below is designed to assist staff in assessing the competency of children. Medical practitioners, adolescents and informed consent project. Rights and interests of children ministry of ethics. For example, re w 29 holds that the gillick competence doctrine does not preclude the parens patriae power for refusals of medical treatment. Child competence to participate in and consent to health.
1442 739 254 1503 909 1234 1052 491 1425 1320 567 104 772 1160 1457 648 565 597 308 923 538 659 338 496 109 796 781 1132 315